thalidomide
The Enemy
- Joined
- Apr 17, 2012
- Messages
- 1,523
- Reaction score
- 53
- Points
- 73
I think we are way off topic
The thing that's so amusing about all this is that Chris Nolan's original "Batman Begins" did NOT even crack the Top 20 weekend openings in comic book movies.
Both "Fantastic Four" films, yes even "Rise of the Silver Surfer" made it ahead over BB.
So when analysis were projecting how "The Dark Knight" would be based on BB's performance, they were projecting around FF or maybe the lower end of the X-Men numbers.
But to have a franchise jump from #22 in "Batman Begins", all the way to #1 in "The Dark Knight" is something really no one foresaw.
It wasn't until Heath Ledger's death that drove the masses to see the buzz about "Ledger's last film before he died". Ledger also had the mass appeal of women from his chick flick days (something Christian Bale doesn't have) which I think to this day, TDK still holds the record for most female audience in the movie theaters for a comic book film at over 50%. Of course, TDK was also a good film that gave itself legs which drove more and more people to see it.
You also have to remember that Warner Bros re-released TDK twice. First on November 14, 2008 and then again on January 23, 2009 and ran it all the way until March. So TDK was around for almost 8.5 months straight in theaters. Both re-releases was what pushed TDK from $996 million and bumped it up to a cool $1 billion.
Yeah, I've been saying the exact same thing over in TDKRs boards, except I've been using the "Empire Strikes Back made less money than Star Wars" analogy, and I totally agree with your points. Although, I didn't expect The Avengers to make so much money.Part of that is that BB was released on a Wednesday. I think it might have cracked the top 20 if released on a Friday. But also BB was more of a slow but steady type release. It held up very well in the following weeks, even if it never made a huge splash.
The film itself sets up the Joker, so I think fans of BB were prepared for the coming movie, When Heath was announced, and the movie started to gain steam and the viral marketing, that pretty much pushed things to the limit.
As I was saying on the TDKR thread, you can only capture lightning in a bottle once. TDKR will make alot of money but you aren't going to see any kind of jump and most likely it may not perform as well.
I bring up SM1 and 2 as an example. Most people think that SM2 is the better film, but it made less money. Well that's mainly because you can't capture what happened with the first film. It was the first movie to break the 100M weekend barrier, and it held that record for several years.
I've said from the beginning that I always thought Avengers was very underestimated when it came to B.O. returns and TDKR was overestimated. I don't know of one single publication before the film was released that thought Avengers would have a chance at being the no. 1 movie of the year at the box office. Now those same pundits are saying it's likely the biggest of the year.
I guess when all is said and done I was absolutely wrong with my prediction.

Keep in mind with TDK, the trailers sold it as much a Joker movie as a Batman movie. By that, I mean it felt like Joker was going to get a lot of screen time. So far, for TDKR, it seems to focus more on Batman disappearing. Bane, and even Catwoman, hasn't really felt like much of a presence in the trailers, unlike Joker. I just don't know if selling the idea of a story about Bruce Wayne being broken and then rising again is enough to give it TDK numbers, but I guess we'll see. At first, I thought both Avengers and TDKR would do about the same total worldwide. But at the rate Avengers is going, it seems less likely.
I would die a happy man if that were to happenJust saw on Box Office Mojo that by this Friday, the Avengers should be a top 6 all time movie. Hopefully by Monday, a top 3 or 4. It's going to take a lot of leg for this to take a top 2 spot.![]()

I hope it ends up number 1. Avatar and Titantic don't deserve the top 2 spots.
70m would mean another recordActuals came in just under the estimates
$103,052,274
I think it should be able to hold 60-70M next weekend, and Battleship will open 55 or under.
(3W)Actuals came in just under the estimates
$103,052,274
I think it should be able to hold 60-70M next weekend, and Battleship will open 55 or under.
Boxoffice.com has battleship opening with 51M; I see it doing even less. The reviews are helping it either.
As much as I'd love to see that, I don't think $70M is happening.Actuals came in just under the estimates
$103,052,274
I think it should be able to hold 60-70M next weekend, and Battleship will open 55 or under.