TMOS Reviews Thread - Non Spoiler Review and Discussion - Part 5

[bapi]

It's gonna finish at 69.

No way. Probably something like 52% could be realistic.

 

[KRYPTON INC.]

Relax, guys, tonight's the night where things will be decided.

With 62%, if the audiences love it, the worst thing that can happen is that posters here won't be able to bring up the "critically acclaimed, here's the RT score" argument. Big deal.

Yeah its like 2 of the biggest reasons fans obsess over things like RT is to pull out the scores to "back up" their arguements or to vaidate their own tastes.

 

[robot]

No way. Probably something like 52% could be realistic.

I wouldn't be surprised at the 'rate' it's falling everyday...

 

[Liam_H]

After its all said and done for it to end up rotten, right now looks like it has a good chance, is pretty surprising.

 

[TheFuture]

Woke up to see it is still going down. Oh well, at least some of the new positive reviews are from top critics.

 

[KillerMcQueen]

^ I think he meant 62, because before he said it would be 57, so according to him 62 may be likely.

either that or he's one pessimistic SOB lol, I'll wait until I see the movie myself to judge, the GA reaction upon it's official release will either change things for the better or keep things about where they are now.

 

[DarthSkywalker]

I was very disappointed. He was more of a tragic hero than a villain. There was no evil to him. Just misled goals.

That to me didn't make him all that enjoyable. He's a bad guy, but not a bad guy. Which made it all the more "meh" when they fought.

- Jow

That angle for Zod actually intrigues me.

 

[smallville fan]

I wonder if the bad scores is the Superman curse at work here, or just angry DBZ fans still ******** that Superman beat Goku.

Well I hope they're happy.

Maybe if we're good children. a JLA movie soon will hopefully get rid of it for us please.

 

[Gianakin_]

That angle for Zod actually intrigues me.

I REALLY can't wrap my head around this one. I thought that'd definitely be a positive.

 

[MarvelU]

No way. Probably something like 52% could be realistic.

I originally said it might end up between 69% - 75% as the reviews started coming in, but it is likely it could dip into Rotten now. Hate to say this but 60% is already technically rotten. It still has a chance to get 65% - 69% after today. Still gonna watch it though, I haven't really read full reviews and will judge it myself.

 

[bapi]

I originally said it might end up between 69% - 75% as the reviews started coming in, but it is likely it could dip into Rotten now. Hate to say this but 60% is already technically rotten. It still has a chance to get 65% - 69% after today. Still gonna watch it though, I haven't really read full reviews and will judge it myself.

Yeah, I'll see that too. However MoS could finish closer to Green Lantern than Batman Begins on RT so I'm quite dissapointed.

 

[KingKane88]

Whats funny, is a vast majority of the positive reviews on RT are from top critics. It's usually the opposite when a movie is in the 60% range. It's almost always top critics bringing whatever movie they are rating down, while the casual critics bump it up a bit.

16 Hours away for me, can't wait!!!!

 

[db85usa]

I originally said it might end up between 69% - 75% as the reviews started coming in, but it is likely it could dip into Rotten now. Hate to say this but 60% is already technically rotten. It still has a chance to get 65% - 69% after today. Still gonna watch it though, I haven't really read full reviews and will judge it myself.

MoS has more rotten reviews than STID. I hope MoS gains more reviews though. I still think it can get at least as high as 75% fresh. Still a ton of reviews out there. Didn't "This is the End" drop down to like the mid 70's? Now it is at 81% with more coming in. That's a current example that a film can climb up on RT. Today and tomorrow will be interesting. I think a lot more reviews will come today.

 

[Jake Cassidy]

16 Hours away for me, can't wait!!!!

I gotta wait 2 more weeks.

 

[MarvelU]

Yeah, I'll see that too. However MoS could finish closer to Green Lantern than Batman Begins on RT so I'm quite dissapointed.

Green Lantern was terrible, and 99% forgettable. I doubt this movie is that bad, and to get to a 26% like Green Lantern then something must be really bad, but I doubt it even dips below 50%.

 

[Sharkboy]

MoS has more rotten reviews than STID. I hope MoS gains more reviews though. I still think it can get at least as high as 75% fresh. Still a ton of reviews out there. Didn't "This is the End" drop down to like the mid 70's? Now it is at 81% with more coming in. That's a current example that a film can climb up on RT. Today and tomorrow will be interesting. I think a lot more reviews will come today.

It will likely be higher by the time all the reviews come in, but i doubt it will break 70% at this point.

The humour isn't lost on me that this will get a lower score than SR, if i had mentioned that on this board last week i would likely have had fire thrown in my face.

 

[Liam_H]

Assuming MoS gets around 300 reviews, the remaining reviews coming have to be 4:1 positive for it to get to 75%.

 

[KingKane88]

I have a really big feeling that public reviews will be in the 80's, while critic reviews will be in the 50's. Just a feeling, but the public goes to a movie to be entertained, and from both negative and positive reviews I read, it's looking as though the positives will win out in the end with MOS. I'm honestly not worried in the least, depends how tomorrow goes though!

 

[db85usa]

It will likely be higher by the time all the reviews come in, but i doubt it will break 70% at this point.

The humour isn't lost on me that this will get a lower score than SR, if i had mentioned that on this board last week i would likely have had fire thrown in my face.

The thing is, people have yet to see it and the GA will likely enjoy this film and it will make decent returns. The one thing that bothers me is when people keep freaking out. A simple Google search, and forums all over the Web are mocking us and the mods because of how we are reacting to RT and some people just going crazy saying things they aren't supposed to or shouldn't. Way too much negativity. It's very depressing. I'm considering signing off at least until Sunday/Monday.

 

[KingKane88]

MoS has more rotten reviews than STID. I hope MoS gains more reviews though. I still think it can get at least as high as 75% fresh. Still a ton of reviews out there. Didn't "This is the End" drop down to like the mid 70's? Now it is at 81% with more coming in. That's a current example that a film can climb up on RT. Today and tomorrow will be interesting. I think a lot more reviews will come today.

IMO your wishing a little to high. The trend seems to be for every 2 fresh, we get 1 rotten, which in our minds should bump the score up, but in reality, and math, the percentage will just keep on dropping.

I'm guessing a final RT of 54%, with a GA score of 81%, with MOS soaring making atleast 700 Mil at the BO.

 

[bapi]

Green Lantern was terrible, and 99% forgettable. I doubt this movie is that bad, and to get to a 26% like Green Lantern then something must be really bad, but I doubt it even dips below 50%.

Green Lantern has 26%, Batman Begins 85% and I can imagine MoS will finish on 53% or so.

 

[DarthSkywalker]

Green Lantern has 26%, Batman Begins 85% and I can imagine MoS will finish on 53% or so.

And this matters how exactly?

 

[KingKane88]

I gotta wait 2 more weeks.

Don't worry buddy, I will be giving my opinion, as well as quotes from the 7 people I have riding with me!!!

 

[Adamlee]

Saw MOS Tuesday and wrote an extensive review. Let me know what you think.

http://www.playmakeronline.com/2013/06/13/review-man-of-steel-2/

 

[Gianakin_]

Very well written, thank you. I can see where you had disagreements with MoS and I will be sure to keep it in mind when I go see it.