I think he is an excellent fit. His films have a very distinct style, unlike directors like Brett Ratner and Paul W.S. Anderson who have generic uninspired work. I hope he can bring some of Brazil's chaos to the streets of Chicago in this film. Moreover, I hope he can make an excellent film so that Hollywood, potentially, will search harder for directors who work on non-English speaking projects.
Frankly, Oldman's involvement doesn't mean too much to me considering he's been in quite a few duds (Paranoia, anyone?). Regardless, I'm sure he'll give a good performance. Also, I don't find the PG-13 rating as big of a deal as other people are making it out to be. This is a new film, with a different direction, and the rating does not determine the tone of the film. And in my opinion, the current gun control climate doesn't reflect the MPAA's rating system. This is still 'Murica, and 'Murica's film rating system has always been easier on violence than something like sex (whereas in Canada and many other countries, it is the other way around - this film will likely get a PG rating if it gets a PG-13 rating in the States).
if this movie is a "hard" PG-13 like, say, The Dark Knight, i'll be good.
so, i saw that Elite Squad 2 was on Netflix streaming and gave it a watch last night. really good movie, i could have done with less voice-over and it felt like the ending needed a tweak somehow, maybe a tad more emphasis on the final action beat, i dunno, but Padilha's talent as a thoughtful storyteller with a penchant for the visceral was obvious. and Wagner Moura was awesome.
interestingly, i found the style of the film to be very guerrilla documentary, lots of semi-shaky hand-held with an emphasis on intense realism...which i didn't mind, but it reminded me of some of the complaints i was seeing on here about "shaky cam" in Elysium. now, i don't know what Padilha's other movies look like, but it seems relatively safe to say that handheld is a big part of his and his DP's aesthetic (also the DP on RoboCop), so i wonder if we will see a marked stylistic difference in how they approach that movie or if we'll be seeing some "shaky cam" in RoboCop, too (kind of weird i'm talking about this in terms of two movies that feature Moura, meanwhile Blomkamp being heavily influenced by the designs and ideas in RoboCop and other early Verhoeven, if not as much by Verhoeven's more staid shooting approach). i'd be fine with either approach, but i'm wondering how bothered some on here might be if we get a new RoboCop with a lot of obvious handheld shots.
the music on Elite Squad 2 was great, same composer for RoboCop. i dunno if we should expect any super memorable themes, but creative and intense? yeaher.

t: