Hopefuldreamer,
My standards for a committed relationship are high, but my standards for a first message are low, because a first message should never be worth more than ten minutes. There is the further issue that if a person sends very few messages, they will get their hopes for each message, which is problematic.
Well I can only tell you my experience.
If you sent me a boring message and your profile didn't grab me, i'm not going to respond.
If you sent me an interesting message, even if your profile didn't grab me, I might respond.
Not a long message. Not even a complimentary one (I'm not big on compliments anyway). Just an interesting one. Whether that means funny, an unusual comment, a weird or out of the box question etc.
I mean, maybe you're not looking for a girl like me
If you're looking for a girl who likes to be complimented, who might care about your financially stable job, who doesn't really care about the message cause they are only judging you by your face... then keep going with what your doing and hope for the best I guess.
This study demonstrates the importance of profile picture, keeping profile content constant:
http://jonmillward.com/blog/attraction-dating/cupid-on-trial-a-4-month-online-dating-experiment/
- Women receive ~20x as many solicitations as men;
- Nearly beautiful women receive the most messages, followed by beautiful women, other women get a lot less;
On smiling:
http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/the-4-big-myths-of-profile-pictures/
The best look for a man, is not smiling and looking off-camera, the opposite of the best look for women.
Something I had forgotten, men's photos are more effective if they show off their six packs. It is in fact not lame. However, I don't have a six pack, I have a one pack, so I won't be posting shirtless pics :P
.
Interesting studies
But I think both are just examples of the problem of quantity over quality. Yes, the more attractive you are, the more messages your get from a lot of the type of people there are on dating websites. So the better you look in your profile picture, the more messages you will get.
But those messages won't necessarily be of any quality or be the kind of people you're looking for. They aren't all going to be relationship prospects.
I mean, I suppose it depends on which dating site you are using.
I can really only comment on POF as it's the only one I used (never paid for one). And there are a lot of guys and girls just looking to hook up on that site. So yeah, you'll get messages if you post abs or cleavage shots. But they aren't the messages you want.
And if you want the kind of girls/guys who don't value abs or cleavage over personality, then take those pictures down... you'll get less messages, but they might be better ones. Cause a girl like me wouldn't message a guy with an ab picture... cause I think it's vain.
In the first study, you might be interested to know that just based on pictures alone, I'd have message the guy in the middle.
His smile looks natural, he doesn't look too well groomed like the 2nd from the right guy (one of my pet hates) or so hot that he's most likely into more attractive women than me like the guy on the far right.
Basically i'm saying that who I would be interested in messaging on a dating site are people I think I might actually have a shot with. I'm not going to send out loads of messages to people who I think are unlikely to be responsive to me.
How well you can judge this is kind of dependant on how good you are at working people out in general.
But I think everyone is capable of being a bit realistic and selective.
At the end of the day, what you are doing clearly isn't working for you, as you described yourself.
So what harm in there is trying another way?
- Swap your professional photos for more natural ones that are semi decent angles/lighting and some that show you are not just a boring serious person... that you can have fun.
- Send out messages to girls whose profiles you've read from top to bottom and think you might click based on your interests. Then put at least 10 minutes of thought into each message and try and use a light and happy tone. Be interested and interesting.
See it like your own personal study.
I can say for certain it will work

but surely it's worth a shot?